Mud Cake with fresh cream

Contested — Dave and Kitty disagreed about this one in the same episode.

Dave

Liked it

Enjoyed the mud cake and loved the cream on it

I like it.

Supermarket 🛒 Cakes 🎂 with Glenn Robbins! · 17 Jan 2026

Kitty

Didn't like it

Found it sticky and plasticky, ranked it last overall

I don't like it. It sticks to my teeth like it's made of plastic.

Supermarket 🛒 Cakes 🎂 with Glenn Robbins! · 17 Jan 2026

Elsewhere on the show

Glenn RobbinsLiked it

Ranked it as his second favourite cake overall

Can I say mud cake number two?

Supermarket 🛒 Cakes 🎂 with Glenn Robbins! · 17 Jan 2026