Mrs. Fields Cookies

Contested — Dave and Kitty disagreed about this one in the same episode.

Kitty changed their mind — Dave didn't

Dave never wavered — still “I love Mrs. Fields” after three and a half years — while Kitty went from worth-the-trip to “now they're a bit sort of flat and greasy”. The positivity gap on a single product.

Aug 2020: Dave loved, Kitty likedFeb 2024: Dave loved, Kitty disliked

Dave

Loved it

Considers it his ultimate cookie

I love Mrs. Fields.

Biscuit three way - Tic Toc, Iced VoVo, Triple Wafer · 29 Aug 2020

Kitty

Liked it

Thinks it's worth a trip to the suburbs for

Worth going to the suburbs for a Mrs. Fields semi sweet choc chip cookie.

Biscuit three way - Tic Toc, Iced VoVo, Triple Wafer · 29 Aug 2020

Elsewhere on the show

DaveLoved it

Fond memory/love of the brand

I love Mrs. Fields.

One Scoop Returns 🍨 · 17 Feb 2024

KittyDidn't like it

Feels quality declined and cookies became greasy over time

Now they're a bit sort of flat and greasy.

One Scoop Returns 🍨 · 17 Feb 2024

Also known as: Mrs Fields Cookie

← All snacks